1
$$Top Pick
213 Google reviews at 4.9 stars. Handy if you would rather sort out coverage across a desk than over the phone.
Bethlehem, Pennsylvania · Christmas City USA
Best Insurance Agents in Bethlehem
Our curated list of the 7 best insurance agents in Bethlehem, PA. Ranked by Google reviews, local reputation, and our team's research. Updated for 2026.
Bethlehem has the deepest insurance roster of the three cities in our rankings, with seven agencies, and none of them reports weekend hours. Every agency that publishes hours on Google is open Monday through Friday only. Elliot Tracey - State Farm on Linden St has the most reviews, more than 700 on Google at a perfect 5.0, which is unusual at that volume. YMI Insurance's Schoenersville Rd office holds a 4.9 average across 213 reviews, and Silver Crest Insurance matches Elliot Tracey's 5.0 across 466. Larry Chapel - State Farm sits at 4.8. Three smaller review records round out the city: Snyder Insurance Agency on Easton Ave (4.9 across 52), Lehigh Partners on Evans St in south Bethlehem (5.0 across 31), and William P Dadio Jr - Allstate on Fairview St (4.5 across 24), the only Allstate agent in our insurance listings. Dadio also keeps the latest weekday hours in the city, until 5:30pm. Snyder does not publish hours on Google, so call ahead before visiting.
Sponsored
2
Elliot Tracey - State Farm
3012 Linden St, Bethlehem, PA 18017
5.0
(713 reviews)✓ Verified October 2026$$
More than 700 Google reviews and still a perfect 5.0, which is a striking combination at that volume.
3
466 Google reviews and a 5.0 average. Worth a call if you are shopping coverage anywhere around Bethlehem.
4
Larry Chapel - State Farm
1135 Stefko Blvd Suite B, Bethlehem, PA 18017
4.8
(113 reviews)✓ Verified October 2026$$
4.8 stars across 113 reviews. Between the free lot and the accessible seating, it is a low-friction visit.
5
$$
4.9 stars across 52 Google reviews. A modest sample, but a consistent one. Google does not list office hours, so call ahead before you visit.
6
$$
A perfect 5.0 from 31 Google reviews. The sample is still small, so read a few before you decide.
7
William P Dadio Jr - Allstate
3640 Fairview St, Bethlehem, PA 18017
4.5
(24 reviews)✓ Verified October 2026$$
4.5 stars from 24 Google reviews, and the office keeps weekday hours until 5:30pm.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where is YMI Insurance in Bethlehem?
YMI Insurance's Bethlehem office is on Schoenersville Rd, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking. It holds a 4.9 rating across 213 Google reviews in our directory data. YMI also has a separate Allentown location on Hamilton Blvd.
What insurance agencies are in Bethlehem, PA?
Seven agencies appear in our Bethlehem rankings: YMI Insurance on Schoenersville Rd, Elliot Tracey - State Farm on Linden St, Silver Crest Insurance on Stefko Blvd, Larry Chapel - State Farm (also on Stefko Blvd), Snyder Insurance Agency on Easton Ave, Lehigh Partners on Evans St, and William P Dadio Jr - Allstate on Fairview St.
Which Bethlehem insurance agency has the most Google reviews?
Elliot Tracey - State Farm, with more than 700 reviews in our directory data. That is the most of any insurance agency we track in Bethlehem, and it still averages a perfect 5.0.
Is there an Allstate agent in Bethlehem, PA?
William P Dadio Jr - Allstate is on Fairview St in Bethlehem. In our directory data it holds 4.5 stars across 24 Google reviews and is open weekdays 8:30am-5:30pm, with wheelchair-accessible parking.
Are Bethlehem insurance agencies open on weekends?
No agency we track in Bethlehem reports Saturday or Sunday hours in Google's verified data. Six of the seven list weekday-only hours, and Snyder Insurance Agency does not publish hours on Google at all.
Are Bethlehem insurance agencies wheelchair accessible?
All seven agencies in our Bethlehem rankings report wheelchair-accessible parking in verified Google data. Five also report an accessible entrance: YMI Insurance, Elliot Tracey - State Farm, Silver Crest Insurance, Larry Chapel - State Farm, and Snyder Insurance Agency. Snyder additionally reports an accessible restroom and seating, and Larry Chapel reports accessible seating.
Insurance Agents Guides for Bethlehem
Car Insurance Allentown PA: Local Agencies Compared
Car insurance in Allentown PA: the five local agencies in our directory, with Google ratings, review counts, office hours, and locations.
Best Insurance Agent in the Lehigh Valley: Independent vs. Captive Agents
Find the best insurance agent in the Lehigh Valley. Compare the top-rated agencies in Allentown, Bethlehem, and Easton by Google rating, review depth, and office hours, and learn what to ask before you choose.
More in Bethlehem
RestaurantsContractorsRoofersHVACPlumbersElectriciansAuto RepairDentistsLawyersLawn Care & LandscapingGolf CoursesWineriesHair SalonsNail SalonsParks & RecreationCoffee ShopsBakeriesBreweriesBarbershopsGyms & FitnessVeterinariansPet GroomingChiropractorsPhysical TherapyEye DoctorsSpas & MassageFloristsJewelersReal Estate AgentsAccountants & TaxCar Washes & DetailingTattoo Shops