Car Insurance Allentown PA: Local Agencies Compared
Quick Answer: For car insurance in Allentown PA, our directory lists five local agencies. YMI Insurance on Hamilton Blvd is the top-ranked agency in our insurance directory, rated 5.0 across 68 Google reviews in our directory data. Shawn Leh - State Farm, Solano Insurance Group, Frank Armetta - State Farm and D E Cressman Insurance Agency round out the list, and all five are rated 4.9 or higher. This page covers where they are, how they are rated and when they are open. Questions about coverage belong with a licensed agent.
Key Takeaways:
- Top of our rankings: YMI Insurance's Allentown office at 3426 Hamilton Blvd, rated 5.0 across 68 reviews in our directory data. YMI also has a Bethlehem office.
- Most reviewed: Solano Insurance Group, with 858 reviews at 4.9 in our directory data.
- Saturday hours: Only Solano (10am to 2pm) and Frank Armetta - State Farm (9am to noon) list Saturday hours.
- Accessibility: Cressman is the only Allentown agency in our data reporting a wheelchair-accessible entrance, restroom and seating.
- Shortcut: See all Allentown insurance agents or the full Lehigh Valley insurance directory.
Which Allentown Insurance Agencies Are in Our Directory?
We list five agencies with Allentown addresses. All ratings, review counts and hours below come from verified Google data in our directory.
YMI Insurance
YMI Insurance at 3426 Hamilton Blvd holds the top spot in our insurance rankings. It is rated 5.0 across 68 Google reviews, open weekdays 9am to 5pm, and reports wheelchair-accessible parking. YMI also runs a Bethlehem office on Schoenersville Rd, rated 4.9 across 213 reviews.
Shawn Leh - State Farm
Shawn Leh - State Farm at 2004 Allen St is rated 5.0 across 591 reviews. It is open weekdays 9am to 5pm and reports wheelchair-accessible parking.
Solano Insurance Group
Solano Insurance Group on Hamilton St is rated 4.9 across 858 reviews, the most of any Allentown agency in our data. Its hours run later than most: 10am to 6pm Monday through Thursday, 9am to 5pm Friday, and 10am to 2pm Saturday.
Frank Armetta - State Farm
Frank Armetta - State Farm on Sumner Ave is rated 4.9 across 258 reviews. It is open weekdays 9am to 5pm and Saturday 9am to noon, and Google lists a free parking lot and wheelchair-accessible parking.
D E Cressman Insurance Agency
D E Cressman Insurance Agency at 2310 Walbert Ave is rated 4.9 across 94 reviews. It opens earliest of the five, at 8:30am, and closes at 5pm Monday through Thursday and 4pm on Friday. It reports a wheelchair-accessible entrance, parking, restroom and seating.
Local rule of thumb: If you can only get to an office outside weekday working hours, Solano and Frank Armetta are the two Allentown agencies in our data with Saturday hours. Every other Allentown agency we list is weekday-only.
How Do the Allentown Agencies Compare on Ratings and Reviews?
All five sit at 4.9 or 5.0, so the star rating alone doesn't separate them much. Review count does:
- Solano Insurance Group: 4.9 across 858 reviews
- Shawn Leh - State Farm: 5.0 across 591 reviews
- Frank Armetta - State Farm: 4.9 across 258 reviews
- D E Cressman Insurance Agency: 4.9 across 94 reviews
- YMI Insurance (Allentown): 5.0 across 68 reviews
A high average across hundreds of reviews and a perfect score on a smaller sample are both strong records. Reading the most recent reviews on each listing will tell you more about day-to-day service than the number alone.
Which Allentown Agencies Carry a Carrier's Name?
Two of the five, Shawn Leh and Frank Armetta, operate under the State Farm name. YMI Insurance, Solano Insurance Group and D E Cressman Insurance Agency operate under their own names. Our directory data doesn't record which insurance companies each agency works with. Ask the office directly.
What If Allentown Isn't the Most Convenient Office?
Many drivers work or commute across the Valley. Our directory also covers Bethlehem insurance agents, including YMI Insurance's Schoenersville Rd office, Elliot Tracey - State Farm (5.0 across 713 reviews) and William P Dadio Jr - Allstate, the only Allstate office in our listings. It also covers Easton insurance agents, including Koch Protect Insurance, which is open until 8pm on weekdays and 9am to 6pm on Saturday. For a Valley-wide view, see our best insurance agent in the Lehigh Valley guide.
Bottom Line: Five Well-Reviewed Local Offices
For car insurance in Allentown PA, our directory lists five agencies, all rated 4.9 or higher. YMI Insurance on Hamilton Blvd leads our rankings. Solano has the deepest review record and Saturday hours, Frank Armetta also opens Saturday mornings, Shawn Leh holds a perfect 5.0 across 591 reviews, and Cressman is the early-opening, fully accessible option on Walbert Ave. Questions about which coverage fits your situation should go to a licensed agent.
Find the best local businesses in Lehigh Valley. Browse our directory of insurance agents in Allentown, Bethlehem, and Easton. These are real, verified local businesses.
